Lots of activity coming to light this week in the fight against the Watchtower’s deadly blood transfusion doctrines. Here are a few stories that stand out.
Monday saw the dismissal of an appeal by Lawrence Hughes, whose daughter Bethany was killed due to her and her mother’s refusal to receive proper medical treatment. Instead of a simple blood transfusion, Bethany was spirited to a secret location by her Jehovah’s Witness mother, where an experimental alternative treatment consisting of arsenic and Vitimin C ultimately led to her demise.
Mr. Hughes had abandoned his Jehovah’s Witness faith to fight for transfusions, refusing to allow his teenage daughter to martyr herself for religion. This made him, under Church rules, an outcast: his wife, his other two daughters, his friends, all shunned him. He has come to refer to the Church as a “cult”; his daughter, he says, was the victim of implicit threats of social and familial ostracism - “disfellowship” they call it. “If you accept the blood transfusion, you lose your family, your friends,” Mr. Hughes says. “It’s like someone standing there with a gun to your head.”
While the appeal was dismissed, Hughes and his lawyer see a subtle victory and progress in the fight against the medical malpractice and doctrinal suicide encouraged by the Watchtower.
“To me, what is significant in this judgment is what it does not say, more than what it says,” says Alice Woolley, a legal ethicist at the University of Calgary.
What it most clearly does not say is that Mr. Hughes is necessarily wrong in claiming that his daughter received problematic advice from lawyers working not just for her, but also for a religious body intent on seeing her denied the blood she needed. “If I was advising [the Watchtower Society and its lawyers] I would now say, ‘At some point, this is no longer going to work out for you,’ ” Ms. Woolley says.
A follow-up article released on Thursday provides a glimpse into Hughes’ continuing legal battle, which has not yet ended, despite the Watchtower’s litigous harrassment and attempts to silence him.
Randy at Freeminds.org forwards on some information from a Watchtower insider familiar with the blood doctrine and one of it’s major proponents, Bethelite Gene Smalley.
Earlier this year, a Russian Jehovah’s Witness mother denied a blood transfusion for her newborn baby. The infant died as a result.
Another story published on Wednesday, reveals JW parents who are attempting to block a necessary blood transfusion for their one month old anemic daughter. A Judge has thankfully overruled their decision, but the parents would still rather see their daughter die than to allow a basic life-saving treatment.
Because of their religious beliefs as Jehovah’s Witnesses, the parents–Stephanie and Pierre Binns–do not want to see their baby girl get any foreign blood, even if it’s a matter of life and death.
When/if this child survives and grows up, I’m sure she would love to find out that her JW parents wanted her to die in the name of their religious beliefs, which she had no choice over, rather than receive basic medical care.
|